ok, to continue this thread a step further, I'm now interested in a CCL handgun for Ann. Can't say that she will carry it (that is my goal for her)
I'd like suggestions for a smaller, female hand and lighter (if possible). No Pink guns, though.
Suggestions? If I can get her buy-in, I want to get her to a range and CCL class as well.
Thanks guys!
Mark,
I would have her try a Ruger LC380, Ruger LC9 or Keltec PF9.
See which of them fits her hand the best and which she feels most comfortable holding and pointing. I suspect she will prefer the Ruger as it has slightly better ergonomics than the Keltec.
I carried the Keltec PF9 for years as a summer shorts pocket gun and it worked well...but it has a fair amount of snap to it with 9mm and might be uncomfortable for Ann to shoot. That is the downside of a lighter more compact handgun.
Hopefully the gun she carries is one that she is not afraid to shoot regularly for training and weapon familiarity.
A .380 would be the smallest caliber I could recommend and it will only marginally have less recoil than a 9mm.
However with a quality copper projectile such as a Hornady HXP...it can be effective for self defense.
I would not consider a .32ACP or even a .22 long rifle or .22 magnum as they simply are not consistently effective. Shot placement becomes critical and with an inexperience shooter it would not be a reliable man stopper.
Stick with a .380 or 9mm.
I would also not consider a small revolver. The heavy double action trigger is hard to master for good accuracy and you are limited to 5 to 6 rounds with tactical reloads being slow and awkward even for an experienced shooter.
Small revolvers also tend to be heavier than small semi autos with polymer frames. Plus it is hard to find a revolver that has good ergonomics. Grips are simply too small and too short. From a safety issue an exposed hammer on a revolver in a womans purse is an invitation for an unintended discharge. Yet with a bobbed hammer you are limited to double action only. Further a .38 special is not a very potent round until you get to a +P and then the recoil becomes an issue.
Stick with an ergonomic small semi auto. The more comfortable in her hand...the better.
HTH
Kerry